Top Rated & Best Selling Baby Crib Mattresses (Top 10)


1. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Baby Crib Mattress, White – The Heavenly dreams crib mattress is firm, lightweight and waterproof. Its vinyl sleeping surface is hypoallergenic and free of phthalates and lead. The sturdy cover is tear resistant, but also resists stains and odors. Its high density thermo-bonded fiber core provides firm and long lasting support. Fits all standard cribs and toddler beds. Meets federal flammability standard 16 CFR 1633 without the use of potentially harmful chemicals, because at Safety 1st your baby’s safety is our number one priority.

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress, White

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress, White

2. Sealy Baby Posturepedic Mattress – Sealy Baby Posturepedic Crib Mattress offers 220 Posturetech coils that sense your baby’s movement and it responds with increasing support and correct support. This has an all around heavy gauge steel border rods maximize side, corner and edge firmness. The steel vertical bars distribute baby’s weight evenly over the entire surface of the mattress. This comes with two non allergenic layers that insulate the mattress for lasting durability.

Sealy Baby Posturepedic Mattress

Sealy Baby Posturepedic Mattress

3. Dream On Me 3″ Playard Mattress, White – Dream on Me 3″ Playard mattress creates a comfortable environment to play and sleep. This exceptional mattress is constructed with quality materials and workmanship in the USA, featuring a hypoallergenic, anti-bacterial waterproof cover that wipes clean with mild soap and water and aids in the prevention of mold, mildew and odor. This mattress also fits the Graco Square Pack n’ Play. Meets Federal Standard Flammability Standard 16-CFR 1633.

Dream On Me 3" Playard Mattress, White

Dream On Me 3" Playard Mattress, White

4. Dream On Me 3″ Portable Crib Mattress – Dream On Me 3 inch Portable Baby Crib Mattress softly cradles your baby with comfort creating a cloudlike environment for your baby to sleep peacefully. Rest easy knowing this mattress is phthalate and lead free and constructed with quality materials and workmanship in the USA. A non-allergenic, anti-bacterial waterproof cover aids in the prevention of mold, mildew and odor. Easily wipes clean with warm water and mild soap. Complies with Federal Standard Flammability Standard 16 CFR 1633. This is a portable crib mattress and fits portable cribs only measuring 38″L x 24″W x 3″H. Does not fit standard size cribs.

Dream On Me 3" Portable Crib Mattress

Dream On Me 3" Portable Crib Mattress

5. Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress – This Sealy crib mattress is the premier foam crib mattress. The Sealy Soybean Foam Core Crib Mattress is lightweight with high density foam made with soybeans. The foam core offers improved durability over conventional foams. The high density foam reduces sagging and provides durability for firm support. The entire cover and lock-stitched binding are wet resistant and wipe clean, preventing allergens from clinging to the crib mattress. This Sealy baby mattress has square-cut corners for snug fit in cribs and can move to a toddler bed as your child grows.

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress

– article continues below –


6. Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress – The Sealy Baby Firm Rest Mattress receives some of the best crib mattress reviews. It is one of the most comfortable yet firm models of baby crib mattress around. A non-allergenic layer provides comfort for an extremely plush sleeping surface. The Sealy crib mattress fits most cribs and toddler bed frames. This mattress is easy to clean, easy to move or lift and has a waterproof surface and binding. Sealy crib mattresses are made in the USA and this crib mattress includes a 20 year warranty on workmanship and material.

Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress

Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress

7. DaVinci Twilight Ultra Firm Deluxe Crib Mattress, 6 inches – This lightweight mattress is firm and flat with a triple laminated cover and cloth binding. It’s non-allergenic and sturdy for perfect safety and serene comfort. We pride ourselves on craftsmanship. That’s why all MDB mattresses are carefully engineered and balanced to be used in any MDB crib. Take a quick look at the four options to see which is best for you.

DaVinci Twilight Ultra Firm Deluxe Crib Mattress, 6 inches

DaVinci Twilight Ultra Firm Deluxe Crib Mattress, 6 inches

8. Dream On Me 3″ Extra Firm Portable Crib Mattress, White – Dream On Me 3″ Extra Firm Portable Crib Mattress gives way to premium support and comfort for your baby. Rest easy knowing this mattress is phthalate and lead free and constructed with quality materials and workmanship in the USA. Features include high density foam, a non-allergenic, anti-bacterial waterproof cover that aids in the prevention of mold, mildew and odor. Easily wipes clean with warm water and mild soap. Complies with Federal Standard Flammability Standard 16 CFR 1633.

Dream On Me 3" Extra Firm Portable Crib Mattress, White

Dream On Me 3" Extra Firm Portable Crib Mattress, White

9. L A Baby Organic Cotton 2 in One Orthopedic Crib Mattress, White – This L A Baby two-sided top selling baby crib mattress is perfect for the infant/toddler. Firmest side for infant, reverses to softer side for toddler use. The cover is an excellent jacquard shadow print. 100% certified organic cotton layers for extra comfort.

L A Baby Organic Cotton 2 in One Orthopedic Crib Mattress, White

L A Baby Organic Cotton 2 in One Orthopedic Crib Mattress, White

10. Colgate Classica I Foam Crib Mattress, White – The most recognized and popular foam crib mattress by name in America. The Colgate Classica I extra firm foam crib mattress was rated No.1 of all crib mattresses tested by one of the nation’s leading consumer products magazines and has been a recommended buy for over fourteen years by another popular baby products publication. High quality extra firm foam as recommended by most medical experts: light weight; orthopedic style, triple layer wetproof cover are all hallmarks of the popular Classica I mattress.

Colgate Classica I Foam Crib Mattress, White

Colgate Classica I Foam Crib Mattress, White

Note: The baby crib mattresses listed on this page are the best selling, top rated baby crib mattresses as of the date this page was last updated. If you know of a top rated baby crib mattress that should be listed on our site, let us know and we’ll review it.

Looking for more!
Check out our top rated baby cribs, baby bassinets, baby cradles, baby diaper changing tables, crib mattresses, glider chairs and ottomans, play yards, and toddler beds.